The 70-Year-Old Landlord's Dilemma: When Age Meets Ambition in Real Estate
A 70-year-old real estate investor posts a complex five-year tax optimization plan involving multiple property sales, 1031 exchanges, and strategic residence swaps. They've just finished installing a 10kW solar system on their roof—by themselves. The contrast between their physical vitality and chronological age sparks a fascinating debate: When should aging real estate investors simplify, and when should they double down?
"You're 70 sell everything and enjoy your time and money," was one younger investor's advice. But the senior investor's response—"Getting old is not part of the plan ;-)"—reveals a fundamental tension in how we think about wealth, age, and the twilight years of active investing.
The Portfolio at 70: Blessing or Burden?
The investor's holdings tell a classic American real estate story:
Current Portfolio Breakdown
- • Primary residence: $600k value, $180k owed, generating $50-60k annually on Airbnb
- • Second home: $350k value, paid off, used when primary is rented
- • Two rental properties: Combined $700k value, generating modest cash flow
- • Raw land: 5 acres worth $50k
Total portfolio value: ~$1.7 million with $1.37 million in equity
For many 70-year-olds, this represents security. For our investor, it represents a problem to solve.
The Five-Year Tax Gymnastics Plan
The proposed strategy reads like a CPA's fever dream:
- Sell rental properties via 1031 exchange
- Purchase new property with DSCR loan
- Convert desert home to primary residence
- Sell desert home after 2 years using $250k capital gains exclusion
- Convert new property to primary residence
- Eventually sell original Airbnb as primary residence
"Your plan with the capital gains exemptions is solid," one tax specialist confirms, before adding layers of complexity about holding periods and conversion rules.
"You are 70 now, your plan is to execute all of this to reduce taxes for a new primary home in 5 years? You really need to examine your goals, and be realistic about it."
The Active Aging Phenomenon
"I'm still very active, just finished putting a 10kW solar system on my house by myself," the investor notes, adding, "But you're right, I am in denial about my age."
This denial—or perhaps redefinition—of aging represents a growing trend. Today's 70-year-olds often bear little resemblance to previous generations. They're installing solar panels, managing Airbnb empires, and plotting complex real estate strategies that would exhaust investors half their age.
The New 70
"70 is Young," argues one commenter. "It may feel old to you as a 28-year-old, but he's not dying soon."
Statistics support this optimism:
- 70-year-old male life expectancy: 84 years
- 70-year-old female life expectancy: 86 years
- That's 14-16 years of potential investing ahead
The Simplification Imperative
Yet several experienced voices advocate for dramatic simplification:
"At 70 OP should be living in a condo with that property money in the bank," suggests one commenter, echoing conventional wisdom about aging and real estate.
The arguments for simplification are compelling:
- Physical Demands: Even active 70-year-olds face increasing physical limitations
- Mental Load: Managing multiple properties, tenants, and tax strategies creates stress
- Health Uncertainty: One health crisis can derail complex investment strategies
- Time Value: Is optimizing taxes worth spending precious years in paperwork?
The Opportunity Cost of Complexity
The investor's elaborate plan to save on taxes reveals a common trap for successful real estate investors: optimizing for money rather than life quality.
"I've been working since I was 12. I'd like to leave something for my kids and enjoy a few years without working."
Yet their proposed strategy involves:
- Moving homes multiple times
- Managing complex 1031 exchanges
- Maintaining rental properties for years
- Navigating DSCR loans and occupancy requirements
One wise commenter notes: "I can't imagine moving into a new house every 2 years at my age, let alone at your age."
Alternative Strategies for Senior Investors
The thread reveals several more age-appropriate strategies:
The Step-Up Basis Strategy
"Kids will get step up in basis to current market value if they get properties thru his estate," notes one commenter. This could eliminate all capital gains with no complex maneuvering—just patience.
The Reverse Mortgage Option
"Consider your second home as your primary and take out a Reverse Mortgage," suggests another, offering liquidity without monthly payments.
The DST Solution
"You can 1031 everything into a DST and not worry about tenants and just live off passive income," proposes one investor, highlighting truly passive options.
The Cash-Out Refinance
"Why not cash out refi and buy new property with that money?" asks one commenter, keeping the appreciating assets while accessing equity.
The Family Dynamic
Hidden in the discussion is a poignant detail: "The goal is to move to a forever home in the city closer to my daughter."
This reveals what might matter more than tax optimization—proximity to family in the final chapters of life. Yet the investor's plan delays this move by years in pursuit of tax savings.
The Early Inheritance Debate
"Strong disagree on not giving it to your kids early," argues one contrarian. "If you die at 84 that means your 'kids' will probably be 60+ when they inherit. Better to give to them in their 20s-30s when they need the money."
The Housing Crisis Subplot
Predictably, some commenters attack the investor for hoarding homes: "This is why there's a housing crisis."
The investor's measured response—"Personally, I think we need to build a lot of homes"—sidesteps the generational warfare while acknowledging the broader issue.
But this criticism misses a crucial point: senior investors often provide quality rental housing and maintain properties that might otherwise deteriorate. The question isn't whether they should own multiple properties, but how to transition those properties responsibly as they age.
The Wisdom of Experience
Perhaps the thread's most valuable insight comes from the investor's 45 years as a Realtor: "One thing I've learned is you can't time the market."
This wisdom seems forgotten in their elaborate tax-timing scheme. They know intellectually that simple often beats complex, yet the allure of optimization proves irresistible.
Lessons for Aging Real Estate Investors
- Energy Is Finite: Being active at 70 doesn't guarantee being active at 75
- Complexity Compounds: Each property and tax strategy adds mental load
- Family Matters More: Proximity to loved ones often outweighs financial optimization
- Perfect Is the Enemy of Good: Sometimes paying taxes beats years of maneuvering
- Legacy Happens Anyway: Step-up basis might achieve the same goal with no effort
The Path Forward
For the 70-year-old investor, several simplified strategies emerge:
Option A: The Clean Break
- • Sell everything except one home
- • Pay the taxes
- • Invest proceeds conservatively
- • Move near family immediately
Option B: Gradual Transition
- • 1031 into single property or DST
- • Keep primary + one backup
- • Use property management
- • Focus on family and health
Option C: Status Quo Plus
- • Keep existing properties
- • Hire full management
- • Use cash-out refinancing
- • Let heirs get step-up basis
The Bottom Line
The 70-year-old investor installing their own solar panels represents both the promise and peril of aging in America. Their vitality challenges ageist assumptions, yet their complex tax optimization scheme reveals how success can become its own prison.
At 70, the question isn't whether you can execute a five-year tax strategy involving multiple property sales and residence swaps. It's whether you should. Time—not tax savings—becomes the scarcest resource.
The investor concluded with rare vulnerability: "I want to thank all of you for your thoughtful contributions, this is a great group."
Perhaps the greatest contribution would be permission to simplify—to choose family over finance, presence over planning, and peace over perfection. Because at 70, getting old might not be part of the plan, but wisdom means recognizing when the plan itself has gotten too old to serve its purpose.
Plan Your Real Estate Legacy Wisely
Whether you're 40 or 70, learn strategies for transitioning your portfolio that balance wealth preservation with quality of life.